Council officers and the bin company apologised to East Suffolk councillors for the summer's missed collections. The committee will agree its recommendations at a later meeting.

East Suffolk Council’s most senior officer on the new bin service apologised to councillors on Thursday for the disruption residents faced this summer. The council’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee spent more than three hours on its review of the rollout, then put off its recommendations to a later meeting.

The committee met at the council’s Lowestoft offices on 12 November. The meeting was shown live on YouTube, and everything quoted here is taken from that recording. The papers are on the council’s meeting page.

We set out the council’s own figures from the review report last week. In June and July, 82.1% of homes on the rounds had at least one food waste collection disrupted.

“The buck does stop here”

Kerry Blair, the council’s strategic director, led the Better Recycling project as its senior responsible officer, and spoke first.

“The buck does stop here in terms of the things we’ll be talking about tonight,” Blair said. It had been “an awful lot harder getting to that point than it should have been”, Blair said. Blair apologised to residents and councillors “where there have been shortcomings”.

The risks had been visible to the project’s sponsor group, which Blair chaired. With hindsight, Blair said, there “might have been times” when pausing or phasing the rollout would have been looked at differently.

Councillor Ashton, the deputy leader, repeated the apology. “We expected there to be teething issues,” he said. “It’s obvious there was more than just teething issues.”

He said the firm delivering the new bins had “in theory delivered them all but in practice had missed lots”. The council only found out as residents began reporting missing bins after go-live.

Lots of small things at once

East Suffolk Services Ltd, the council-owned company that runs the collections, sent its board chair and directors. The company listed the problems that hit together:

  • recruiting HGV drivers and mechanics, which it called a national shortage
  • new food waste lorries arriving late, with hired vehicles of the wrong specification used for several weeks
  • routing assumptions, which it called a Suffolk-wide issue
  • tip queues of up to an hour and 40 minutes, against the 15 minutes the modelling assumed

“Individually these things are risks that were understood and known about,” one of the company’s directors told the committee. “I don’t think anyone believed all of them would happen at once.” The same director said “lots of small things added up to something that ended up being quite catastrophic for residents”.

Cassandra Clements, the company’s managing director, said the money given to councils across Suffolk for the change “did not meet the need of what the actual rollout would be”.

What councillors asked for

When the debate turned to recommendations, councillors raised several ideas:

  • tell parish clerks when collections in their parish fail, using the street data the council now holds
  • give the crews who run the rounds a stronger say in future projects
  • set out a short action plan for winter and the Christmas collections, with regular updates to councillors
  • report back on what has been done about each of the review’s nine “strategic lessons learned”
  • a gesture to the areas still affected before Christmas, such as homes still waiting for garden bin lids
  • an independent review, which another councillor said there may not be time for before the council elections next May

The chair said there was “an enormous amount of work to do”. The committee voted unanimously to finish its recommendations at an online meeting in the next fortnight or so. The chair said its next formal meeting, on 19 November at East Suffolk House in Melton, would review East Suffolk Services in private.

The better news

Councillor Ashton said the latest figure he had put recycling at 58% of household waste, against 44% before the change. The government’s target is 60%. The review report itself gives 55.6% for July to September, up from 43.6% a year earlier.

What it means for you

  • Still missing a collection or a bin lid? Report it on the council’s bin collections page. The report said about 10,500 replacement garden bin lids were still to be fitted, with the work due to finish by the end of the year.
  • Want to put a point to the committee? Contact your ward councillor before the recommendations are agreed. Councillors said they want a plan for the Christmas collections in place first.

We will report the committee’s recommendations when they are agreed.